Friday 30 September 2022
Home / none / CDC gives nod to Lummis-Gillibrand bill in proposed amicus brief in SEC v. Ripple case

CDC gives nod to Lummis-Gillibrand bill in proposed amicus brief in SEC v. Ripple case

The Chamber of Digital Commerce (CDC) has requested to file an amicus brief in the case of the United States Securities and Exchange Commission v. Ripple Labs and its executives Bradley Garlinghouse and Chris Larsen. Liliya Tessler of the firm Sidley Austin filed a package of documents, including the proposed brief, with the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of New York on Wednesday.

The CDC is the world’s largest blockchain and digital asset trade group, with over 200 members that include industry players, investors and law firms. It argued that the Chamber does not have “a view on whether the offer and sale of XRP is a securities transaction,” but it is interested in “ensuring that the legal framework applied to digital assets underlying an investment contract is clear and consistent,” adding:

“Maintaining this distinction is critical to developing a predictable legal environment through a technology-neutral precedent, which this Court has the power to do.”

The documents later restate the question as “whether the well-settled law applicable to the offer and sale of an investment contract that is a securities transaction is properly distinguished from the law applicable to secondary transactions in digital assets that were previously the subject of an investment contract” in light of the fact that “no federal law (or regulation) specifically governs the legal characterization of digital assets recorded on a blockchain.”

In the proposed amicus brief, the CDC acknowledges the “fact-intensive” Howey test, which:

“is at times difficult for even experienced lawyers to apply, let alone market participants without legal training.”

The CDC asked the court to reiterate the difference between contracts that are securities and the subjects of those contracts, which are not securities. The cases cited include a hodgepodge of subject items, as is already customary in these discussions. Here, cases involving whiskey casks, payphones, condominiums and beavers were mentioned.

Related: SEC objects to XRP holders aiding Ripple defense

The CDC continued its argument saying that the SEC has “commendably provided guidance on the application of securities laws,” but “the SEC’s enforcement approach, similarly based on Howey, paints a different picture” and the agency has failed to provide guidance to market participants who have requested it.

The CDC continues that the SEC is using in its case against Ripple a novel application of contract analysis of secondary transactions with assets subject to an investment contract, but has not provided guidance on how to apply that analysis. Nonetheless, the SEC still expects market participants to determine whether or not an asset is a security.

The CDC noted the lack of precedent on secondary transactions with the subjects of securities contracts but stated:

“The Chamber believes that, as long as the underlying asset does not include financial interests, such as legal rights to debt or equity, digital assets are presumed to be commodities.”

The CDC noted that the proposed Lummis-Gillibrand Responsible Financial Innovation Act (RFIA) took the same stance when it introduced the concept of “ancillary assets” into consideration. Furthermore:

“The Chamber respectfully asks that this Court draw upon the principles set forth in RFIA for guidance if it decides to clarify the characterization of digital assets, which are the subject of an investment contract or defer such a decision to the legislature.”

Original Article

About Jude Savage

Check Also

Ethereum Merge was ‘executed flawlessly,’ says Starkware co-founder

As the dust settled over the Ethereum network’s highly-anticipated transition to proof-of-stake (PoS), Eli Ben-Sasson, the co-founder of Starkware, gave his thoughts on its execution and potential for the future. Speaking to Cointelegraph’s Gareth Jenkinson at the Token2049 event, Ben-Sasson shared his thoughts on the current situation post-Merge and how it affects layer-2 projects like Starkware. In addition to that, the executive also gave his thoughts on the adoption and interest for layer-2 products and the crypto winter. Looking back at the Ethereum Merge’s execution, Ben-Sasson rejoiced that the transition was flawless and said things happened as they should. The executive explained that: “The most important thing is that it was executed flawlessly. Everything that was supposed to happen did happen. And none of the things that people were worried about did happen. And that's terrific news.”Additionally, the executive also highlighted the importance of the new Ethereum netw..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *